Hello dear
Welcome To Owl's Nest
Owl's Nest, located in Poynette, WI, welcomes patrons to a charming, retro dining experience. Recently under new management, the eatery offers a delightful menu featuring locally-loved dishes such as their famous fish fry, mouthwatering walleye, and hand-breaded mushrooms. Guests appreciate the inviting ambiance and friendly service, although some mention room for improvement as the staff adjusts to new operations. The signature Old Fashioned made with brandy has become a standout among regulars. With an evolving menu and a commitment to quality, Owl's Nest promises a homey atmosphere where both familiar favorites and exciting new culinary adventures await.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Wisconsin Cheese Curds
12oz Rib Eye With 3 Gulf Shrimp
12 Oz Pork Chop
Saturday - Prime Rib Certified Herford
About
Owl's Nest
Welcome to Owl's Nest, a cozy dining destination nestled at 617 E North St, Poynette, WI. Recently rejuvenated under new ownership, this charming establishment invites you to share in a delightful culinary experience. While they embrace the challenge of perfecting service, the heart of Owl's Nest lies in its excellent food, which is already winning over diners.
Food Quality: Renowned for its delectable offerings, Owl's Nest boasts a diverse menu that includes standout dishes such as home-breaded mushrooms and mouthwatering walleye. Diners rave about the Old Fashioned, made with brandy, which perfectly complements a good meal. The salad bar is another highlight, adding a fresh touch that many guests appreciate, although some noted the timing of dish arrivals could improve.
Atmosphere: Step inside, and you’ll find a warm, retro vibe that instantly makes you feel at home. It's a place where new memories can be created around hearty meals with friends and family. The team's dedication to enhancing your dining experience shines through, even as they navigate the typical pitfalls of being a new restaurant. Patrons have expressed gratitude for their commitment to quality food and service.
Community Connection: Owl's Nest isn’t just about food; it’s about connection. Customer feedback reflects a supportive community eager to see this location thrive. As the new owners continue to settle in, positive sentiments shine through, showcasing a willingness to learn and adapt to the needs of their patrons. Regulars miss the previous family but are optimistic about the new chapter that Owl's Nest is beginning.
In conclusion, Owl's Nest is a fresh culinary gem worth visiting. Whether you're in the mood for a delicious fish fry or a comforting plate of ribeye, there's something for everyone. Enjoy a meal at Owl's Nest and experience the merger of old traditions with new ambitions. Your appetite is in for a treat!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Excellent food, staff needs to be trained, bartenders and wait staff, they all where trying but had no real game plan on serving the customers, just sorta all over the place, we had 4 different people wait on us. Went there after 7:30 pm no crowd walked right in, good salad bar, but our food came out just as we got the salad. ”
“ The new Owners (Mark) are great and are here to make your dining experience the best possible. Obviously, they're still working out the kinks of being a new restaurant, so be a little patient and don't judge them too harshly if everything isn't perfect.None of us are perfect. We will definitely be back soon. ”
“ Awesome, homey and retro! They make an amazing Old Fashioned with brandy and the walleye was to die for! Worth the drive for me! Such nice people, too! Hand breaded mushrooms? Hell yes! Will be back for the bluegill and ribeye. ”
“ Our first visit since the remodel. So happy and best wishes for continued success to the new owners! All food was delicious- fish fry, salad bar, rolls, potatoes, etc. Can't wait to come back and try different items! Thank you!! ”
“ It was the last night for the Zuege family. Years of good food and good times! They will be missed! I hope the new owners continue to serve the best fish fry in the Madison area. Love and good luck to all! Santa ”
“ All legit hometown supper Club. They did a great job of accommodating our group of 16 for my parents 50th anniversary. A decent salad bar, good selection of bottle and can beers, and food that made everyone happy. My fish was good (but not quite great) and everyone who had the prime rib loved it. Sweet.potato fries and tater tots cooked to perfection. ”
“ We went here for the first time tonight for Prime. Got the king, it was amazing. Cooked to perfection. Low key, relaxed place. Everyone working was so nice. We definitely will be back. ”
“ We were there with our neighbors on "Opening Night." Got there about 5:30 and ordered drinks. Our brandy old fashioneds were very good! We waited a bit for a table, but it was worth it to see some old friends. There were a couple of mix ups on our order, but the food was great. I really liked the full salad bar and make sure you try the hash browns! The Owls Nest has been a local favorite for many years. My connection goes back to childhood! The decor is clean, tidy, and warm. A few first night jitters were totally understandable!! Try it for yourself and see. ”